Category Archives: News

Why Jordan’s newest water source may be bad news for Jordanians

Mohamed Yusuf is 60 years old and raised seven sons and a daughter on his teaching salary in Saudi Arabia. He returned to Amman 15 years ago and hasn’t had a steady supply of water in his household since the day he got back. Starting this summer, though, the three days of supply he receives carries his family through the whole week and leaves enough for washing the car. Now he sells juicy produce to cover household expenses.

It’s hard to see the downside in this new improvement in access, and most Jordanians above a certain income level have nothing but positive things to say.

Currently the world’s second water-poorest country, Jordan has rationed domestic water for 30 years. At the same time, it dumps between 60 and 90% of its water resources onto citrus, banana and other water-guzzling crops designated mostly for export in Europe. Revenues support 3% of Jordan’s GDP and an undeniably luxurious lifestyle for the handful of wealthy producers.

Rather than a reallocation of water from farms to residents, the solution to Jordan’s drinking water crisis has taken the form of tapping a great, unsullied ancient aquifer near the Saudi border – one that Alexander the Great named on his list of conquests 2300 years ago.

The Disi Aquifer was supposed to supply water for 35 years while the world figured out how to make desalination cheap.

The trouble was, Disi wasn’t full of the promised 10 billion cubic meters of water – it had closer to 2.2, enough to last Amman 16 years at best. Also, it wasn’t as pristine as proposed – it’s heavily laced with radionuclides, making it carcinogenic for those who drink it.

The pipeline from Disi to Amman has gone forward all the same, funded by US and European development banks. Last summer the water started flowing to households in Amman.

Evaluating whether the Disi pipeline is positively impacting the right to water is complicated. Jordanians were previously receiving inadequate quantities of water, making additional resources essential. But now the Disi water is flowing at unsustainable rates through fractured pipelines where up to half the water is lost into the soil and down secret siphons attached to the swimming pools and gardens of the wealthy and powerful. And it may be poisoning those who drink it.

Water remains cheap here — cheaper even than the US. Denverites pay $0.75 per cubic meter of water — Jordanians pay half that. Among the upper and middle class, this has not promoted efficiency. People wash cars weekly, sweep patios with a running hose and plant citrus trees in their gardens. The median on my street here in Amman is a block-long water fountain.

Asked whether they believe the Disi water will last for many years, people say, “God will supply us with the water we need.” It might be more efficient to get it from the farmers, though.

 

If you ever thought NomoGaia would make its way into Food & Wine…

… you had foresight that I lacked.

But here we are!

“Industry-loved Momofuku beverage director Jordan Salcito founded Bellus (“beauty” in Latin) to collaborate with some of her favorite producers on  affordable, delicious terroir-driven bottles. Her latest releases include the 2013 Bellus Scopello Frappato, a lively, cherry-scented red with a great backstory. The wine’s superb in its own right, but the really cool thing about it is that Salcito is donating a portion of its sales to NomoGaia, an NGO run by her sister, Kendyl.”

Read the full blog post here.

Wine for Women’s Rights!

Yesterday Bellus Wines launched a new red and announced that proceeds will support NomoGaia.

The wine, “Scopello” is made with Frappato grapes from Vittoria, Sicily. Grapes are grown without chemical fertilizers, herbicides or pesticides, supplied by smallholder grape growers in the area. Bellus connects these producers to broader markets, supporting the Sicilian economy while protecting workers and the environment.

Bellus is a female-owned business dedicated to building relationships among working women and producing wine in a sustainable manner. It occupies a rare space in the agricultural supply chain where child labor is categorically absent and where eco-friendly growing and harvest techniques are inherent to the quality of products. (Full disclosure: Bellus is owned by my sister, Jordan Salcito.)

Contributions from Bellus to NomoGaia will support our work addressing gender disparities in project sites, helping ensure that women benefit equally from globalization.

Buy Scopello online at www.belluswines.com … who knew drinking could be so rights-friendly!?

 

What is human rights due diligence without human rights? A World Bank workshop

What is human rights due diligence without human rights? A World Bank workshop

While Mark was gallivanting with experts in Switzerland, Kendyl was back in DC at a World Bank meeting on a similar topic. The World Bank and SHIFT co-hosted an expert workshop on “Human Rights Due Diligence in Development” on September 16.

Mark’s meeting was interesting because the leading experts on HRIA for trade agreements agreed that no real methodologies had emerged for effective evaluation of the impacts of global trade on human rights. NomoGaia’s work was viewed as groundbreaking because, though it was oriented toward large-footprint projects, rather than bilateral trade, it involved actual, field-based evaluation.

Kendyl’s meeting was interesting because leading experts on HRIA for the World Bank suggested no methodology is needed.

As a development agency and an investor that has engaged with the UN Guiding Principles on Business and human Rights, the World Bank Group should, at a minimum, commit to “respect” human rights. That would require Bank projects to undergo evaluation for the human rights risks they pose to affected communities. As our past work on the World Bank’s Myanmar power sector investments has shown, no such due diligence is occurring, and major risks are present.

Why is the World Bank resisting human rights responsibilities? Politics are certainly an issue. One Bank insider lamented that country representatives call his office every week to influence him in one direction or another on the topic of human rights.

Perhaps another barrier is that the World Bank is receiving weak guidance on human rights due diligence. One participant at the workshop presented his most recent work on HRIA, on a project in a South Asian country. His findings depicted negative impacts, but his conclusions focused on the other players that posed equal or greater harms to human rights in the project area, not his company’s own impacts. His assessment methodology didn’t include engagement with rightsholders, but he represented this data gap as a regrettable necessity.

NomoGaia’s commitment to rightsholders through methodological rigor is what has made our assessments affect change. The companies with which we’ve worked have modified policies, adjusted operations and shifted perspectives. The World Bank clearly needs more evidence of good practice, and we are committed to providing that.

The right impact? Expert workshop on evaluating Human Rights Impact assessment (HRIAs) in trade and investment regimes

Trade and investment treaties are essential legal conduits of the world’s economy. In the rising tide of globalization and the rush to reduce trade barriers there is a countercurrent of opinion that freer trade often harms the most vulnerable. There has been a movement to use the human rights lens to identify those losing out in trade liberalization. Human Right Impact Assessments have been performed on various aspects of international trade and investment agreements. The human rights work in the area of trade and investment treaties has developed in parallel with the development of human rights impact assessment in the corporate sphere.

In order to connect these related, but separate discourses, Nomogaia was invited to participate in a high level expert workshop sponsored by the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner of Human Rights and the well-respected nonprofit Friedrich-Ebert Stiftung. The multi-day gathering included respected authorities from academia, government, NGOs and international institutions. It was called “Making the right impact? Expert workshop on evaluating Human Rights Impact assessment (HRIAs) in trade and investment regimes” and was held at a conference center outside of Geneva, Switzerland.

We were specifically invited to share NomoGaia’s experience with HRIA with the trade and investment treaty world. It was gratifying to hear NomoGaia called a “pioneer” and its work “ground breaking” and “inspiring.” There was keen interest in spreading NomoGaia’s learning, experience and techniques to the trade and investment realm.

Mark Wielga represented Nomogaia at this event. None of your donations were used to cover the expenses.